Bridle Trails New York Pizza

06/05/11

Seriously... Pretty BAD! Filthy Inside too!

by MNandM at Citysearch

After moving into the area, we found this place to be one of the only places around. Had a couple of decent pizza's the first time around, but it has been completely down hill since. For the last year, there has been something seriously wrong with every pizza we ordered. They are exteremely inconsistant. Last night I found a long curly black hair baked into the dough. That was it for me... enough is enough.

The last positive review, reads oddly alot like their website... Hmmm.

Don't wasted your time.

01/21/10

Amazing food, great place to go

by Dantheman94 at Citysearch

I have been going to New York Pizza (the artist formerly known as Piecora's) for over 7 years. It is a great family owned pizza joint and has authentic new york style pizza. The staff members are personable and friendly. They really seem to like their jobs (as you can see when they sing and air-guitar to classic rock music) which makes the atmosphere very unique. Overall, great food, great service and very kid friendly. Be sure to check out the arcade while your there, its super awesome.

• Pros: The pizza, service and kid friendly
• Cons: Non

09/15/09

The worst!

by CL3PS at Citysearch

I gave them my business because as a kid, I enjoyed this place - either they've changed or thankfully, my tastes have refined!

The pie crust was thin with a texture like a wet paper plate & the outer crust was thick but overcooked, tough, too chewy with no flavor. The sauce was bland, I could only identify pureed tomatoes & a sprinkle of oregano & so wet that the cheese & toppings slipped off the soggy crust with every bite! Being overcooked, the toppings lost their savory flavor. Veggies & herbs shouldn't be burnt & crispy.

Quite expensive, added 5 non-meat toppings to a medium cheese pizza & it came out to $23! Each topping cost $1.80 - why does minced garlic cost the same to add as grilled chicken? Now I know why there was a need for their competitor to open another pizzeria walking distance away across the parking lot! I'll got there next time, wish I had this time!

• Cons: overpriced, overcooked, poor quality ingredients

09/11/09

Old Pizza

Contributor at Citysearch

The pizza was very bland. The staff would no accomidate my request to keep a small portion of the pizza plain cheese.

09/02/09

I Will Never Walk into this Place Again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by noff72 at Citysearch

It does not get much worse than this joint.

I called this place to order a take out pizza for three adults and a child. I ordered a multi-topping pizza for the adults and requested that a quarter of the pizza be left cheese-only as the child would not like the toppings.

I was informed that "they do not do quarter pizzas." I politely asked that they consider an exception, noting that I was not asking them to cook four different quarter pizzas but rather just asking for a small portion to be left without toppings for a child. After speaking to the manager the girl on the phone very rudely refused to make the pizza as I requested.

I arrived to pick up my pizza and spoke with the manager and explained my dissatisfaction. He was twice as rude as the girl on the phone and just “walked away” in the middle of our conversation.

To top this all off, the pizza was some of the worst pizza I have ever had. The place embarrasses the City of New York by sticking its name on its outdoor signage. The Caesar salad I ordered was bland, and contained nothing more than lettuce and “grocery store brand” caliber croutons and dressing. Avoid this place at all costs!!!

• Pros: None other than that I don't have to go back
• Cons: Rude Staff/Management; Legendarily Bad Food; Dirty