Andy's Diner--CLOSED

12/13/07

You can get lost and die in there.

by crampton

There is a bartender, Mel, with a joy of life and rosy cheeks that allow her to reap giant tips from drunken pensioners. They have 151 <i>and</i> Cointreau. In the summer, the neighborhood smells like hot garbage. It's obviously a front for something.

p. s. Keep your eye out for the skinny trucker "Harvey the Hillbilly B*stard" guy slumped over at the end of the bar...he's been trying to put the make on Mel and she may have been stringing him along a little bit. Don't say anything sideways to Mel or else he get his hackles up.

• Pros: Mel, booze.
• Cons: Heard weird noises coming from somewhere in the labyrinth of hollowed-out railcars.

02/01/07

Not Very Good

by angieray713

While the atmosphere and service were very very good, the food itself was very bad. My boyfriend and I went there on a Saturday morning just to check it out. He ordered the pancake breakfast which was huge! But he said it was pretty good. I ordered a simple two egg breakfast with sausage. I ordered the eggs scrambled soft with cheese and got egss that were so hard, if I dropped some on the floor you would have heard it. And I didn't get the cheese on top. The sausage was so of the worst I have ever tasted in my life! They really need to drop their supplier! The sausage wasn't cooked thouroughly. It was literally the worst breakfast I ever tried to eat. Sure the fact that it's a train is interesting, but if you want good food, you will have to go elsewhere.

• Pros: Good service, Great atmosphere
• Cons: Lousy food, it's cold in there!

10/04/06

it's the food and service

by epotato

Kitch is still alive at Andy's Diner. Great service from friendly wait/bar staff - all in classic rail road cars! My grandparents would take me here for sunday dinner 25 years ago and my recent meal was just as i remembered it. The food is good old fashioned diner food. Not fancy, not low fat, just good - the best hash browns i've had in years and you have to try the Prime Steak. I loved it and would totally go back!

• Pros: Food, Service
• Cons: a little dated - but that's the point