Cellar 46

10/16/10

Bad Experience...Would Never Eat Here Again

by DrewG35 at Citysearch

The only good thing I can say is that we had excellent wine and the desserts were decent.

The bad...every meal in our party of 6 people had issues. 3 people ordered the filet. All 3 filets came to the table well done. 2 were ordered meduim rare and 1 medium. 1 person ordered salmon and it came out over done as well. Crab cakes and a chicken dish were the other 2 people. Both those dishes came out cold and the chicken was very rubbery due to overcooking.

The menu is over priced for the amount of food you get. We ordered 2 appetizers and we were very disappointed in the portion size.

Just not a good place to eat. I would only go back there if I was asked to grab a drink at the bar.

07/21/10

Excellent service, great wine flight, food good.

by MI Rater at Citysearch

I went here today with a friend to take advantage of their happy hour. It might be because they weren't terribly busy, but the service was excellent and perfectly attentive. Even after the place filled up, there was still appropriate attention. The wine flight was very good and educational. (Note: You get a lot of wine for $10, and I couldn't finish it.) I had the antipasti plate, which was acceptable - but the server made sure we had a neverending supply of bread. I would definitely go there again, probably with a friend who would share the glasses with me. Fun experience.

• Pros: Very generous wine flight w/ excellent wines; great service
• Cons: Food is not amazing but prices are OK

01/26/10

Loved it!

by Mr Casitas at Citysearch

I live on Mercer Island and I have yet to step foot in Cellar 46, until last weekend. I showed up to meet an old friend during their Happy Hour (good deals on wine by the glass and an impressive wine list!) and we ended up hanging out and meeting other people at the bar. We almost closed the place down we were having so much fun. If you want to meet people and be social, I recommend getting a seat at the bar. Staff if friendly too. But if you want to relax and not be bothered, then grab a table and open a bottle of wine. Two thumbs up! I will be back for sure!

• Pros: Great place to meet up with friends

10/01/09

Great Food

by Lance2 at Citysearch

Had a fantastic meal at Cellar 46. The seem to have made some changes since I was there a few months ago, because this was a great experience. Lance

• Pros: Value

07/19/09

don't come here if you're hungry...

by iamslee at Citysearch

40 minutes to cook a medium steak and chicken is a ridiculous amount of time. Especially when there were only 4 other dining guests in total in the restaurant.

However, the "medium" steak was not so medium as it was "well done". No point in complaining to wait another 40 minutes for them to fix it.

Server was nice though.

• Pros: Server was nice.
• Cons: Food could be better.