02/23/09

It gets no Better..

by 3rdTimesaCharm

You simply cannot eat a better pizza than Pegasus Pizza. Whether you like the traditional mixes of flavors such as pineapple and canadian bacon or your tastes run to the more gourmet style encompassing sun-dried tomatoes, sunflower seeds and proscuitto, Pegasus will make your tastebuds sing!

Be prepared to wait (and wait some more), especially on weekends and any relatively sunny day, due to its location right on Alki's beautiful beach. But it's well worth it.

• Pros: wonderful food, noisy and fun, fabulous view
• Cons: wretched parking on the street --RIGHT ON ALKI--Good Luck!

11/29/08

Great pizza while visiting a great area of Seattle!

by norge79seattle

The Greek Salad is a must! It's huge so it can be shared with 3-4 people, and the price is very reasonable. The pizza comes deliverd to your table bubbling hot. We have tried them all and vote all are great! Please go and take your friends. It will become one of your favorites!

• Pros: Price for the amount of food you get.
• Cons: Parking can be tricky on hot summer days.

07/19/08

Worst customer serivce, wait staff are rude and ugly.

by coum

Lets just say the wait staff our a bunch of dumb snatches and if i ever go back there i will have most definitley kick some a**. There rude inconsiderate dont no a lick a about customer service and need to learn when to pick there battles. If you like pizza but have to wait 30 mins for your pizza and try and be told how a long a pizza takes to cook when your inquiring about your food then i suggest you go here. Also if your trying to pay for your food and like it when the manager gives you attitude and doesnt know a lick about managing a resturant or staff yeah come here. There's all that and then some...god stoopid people.

• Pros: food
• Cons: service

07/03/08

Delicious pizza!

by BabyWaves

Great atmosphere being right on the beach on Alki - went there once after a soccer tournament and have gone there every time I've been in West Seattle since - well worth the trip!

06/25/08

Poor Service

by PegagusPizzaHater

Busy, sunny evening. Ordered a takeout pizza. pay upfront and wait inside. Promised a pizza in 10 minutes. 25 Minutes goes by, ask waitress to check on the order. Assured that its coming. 35 minutes. Ask Manager about it, assured that order is placed and coming. 60 minutes. Still no pizza. Ask for a refund. Manager gives wrong change back (down 1 dollar), promises a free large pizza in 8 minutes. Wait 8 minutes. no pizza. Leave hungry, frustrated, out 1 dollar for having waited 1:15 minutes for nothing. To be fair, they were extremely busy with a wedding party coming in, however, they should have been upfront about the wait time and actually checked if the kitchen had the order.

01/14/08

Best pizza in Seattle? Really? Have you gone anywhere else?

by thejuggernaut

This highly overrate pizzeria manages to turn out a product that's consistently greasy and bland. To be fair, I've not tried the salads, but when I go to a pizza joint, it's because I want pizza. This has to be hands down the most overrated restaurant I have ever encountered. It seems that anyone that's lived in West Seattle for any length of time will invariably swear by Pegasus, even people who normally have good taste. Perhaps there's something in the drinking water that makes West Seattleites crave bland pizza enough to brave the lack of parking to get it. It just doesn't make sense, especially with a Pagliacci being available.

• Pros: You're in Alki, enjoy the view
• Cons: Pizza, parking, service can be slow, even when empty

08/07/07

Best Pizza on Alki!

by trcress

Pegasus Pizza was recommended by my boss. He lived in Seattle for 6 years and said it was the best place in Seattle. He was right! This was the best pizza I have had in a long time. It has a style all it's own and a HUGE array of toppings! Extremely tasty. Our service was superb and the view of Alki was amazing!

• Pros: Service, Food, View, and Value! All excellent!
• Cons: None

08/06/07

delicious pizza

by 123cindylou

It's a great location to grab a greek salad and a pizza then walk to the beach and enjoy the sun. They have a patio, but it doesn't get sun until around 4. The meatball pizza is to die for.

08/04/07

Fantastic soup and salad, plus great pizza!

by gemini23

The soup is homemade and always really tasty. Their minestrone soup is the best I have ever had. The salads are huge and the ingredients are always fresh. They also have excellent grinders and subs. I can't remember a meal that we have eaten there that wasn't delicious. Plus, their prices are very reasonable. You get a lot of food for your money.

• Pros: Lots of food, consistently good meals
• Cons: Too hard to get to

11/18/06

Great pizza

by kee22

The pizza here is pretty good. My friend and I went to eat..and we were promptly seated. Our waitress was very nice and the pizza did not disappoint at all. I think that this location is a lot better than the Renton location.

• Pros: Great pizza, good service