Pagliacci Pizza - Broadway Pizzeria

09/15/2008 Posted by markdavidh

It seems to obvious to call Pags the best pizza in Seattle, but it could be true. They certainly have the best crust. There is also a great selection of toppings. There is also a nice atmospere and it's clean.

08/21/2008 Posted by changnan

2 slices of Pepperoni pizza at Pagliacci Pizza is $5.40 some odd sense, and that includes tax. One slice at Pagliacci Pizza costs...less than $2 1/2 bucks. Great deal. I love Pagliacci's crust. Always a great choice. Pagliacci Pizza delivery ROCKS! We love Pagliacci Pizza. And they just named the best all time pizza in Seattle by The Seattle Weekly i.e. a trophy and lifetime achievement award for Seattle's Favorite Pizza (not for the year...forever).

Pros: pizza, salads, slices, whole pies, delivery

Cons: we need a location in Leschi or Madison Park

05/02/2008 Posted by anythingatall

"Gourmet" pizza can be fantastic: exotic ingredients layered in inspired combinations, just the right olive oil, a nice biting marinara or bolognese sauce (or a garlic cream sauce with clams), etc. Unfortunately, for all its lauds as a premier pizza vendor in Seattle, every pie I've had from Pagliacci's has had remarkably little flavor. Maybe it's because they seem to have a law that toppings should never touch one another, or that pizza sauce should resemble tomato soup base, or that a thin crust pizza should be alternately hard as a Rye-Krisp or have the tensile strength of a paper towel (on the same pizza, mind you). If you're on Broadway, go two blocks north and have something really good at Bella Pizza (next to FedEx-Kinko's behind the fountain); on Queen Anne or the University district, try Mad Pizza. Anywhere else in the city, you can probably find good pizza within half a mile of Pagliacci's -- and you'll probably be happier.

Pros: they're everywhere

Cons: a regret in every bite

04/18/2008 Posted by AmericanBamba

I would highly recommend this company. I order delivery regularly and they are always on time. I have never had to wait more than 45 minutes. The pizza tastes fabulous, and it's always consistent in taste and quality. Customer service on the phone is positive and helpful. Pagliacci is a bit pricy, but well worth it. I even got a free pizza for being a "frequent flyer."

Pros: Speedy delivery. Great Customer Service. Timely. Great Quality.

Cons: Pricy.

02/16/2008 Posted by merlinmc

Excellent. Among the very best pizza I've had anywhere. The restaurant could be a little cleaner.

11/18/2007 Posted by jeannqpublic

It is an added bonus that when I call for delivery, they have my favorites on file. Always good service.

Pros: Good Delivery, Good Restaruants

11/09/2007 Posted by limonata

Pags has a bad rap and I have never been able to figure out why--for classic NY-style pizza, I think it might be the best in town. The seasonal primo pizzas, like one right now covered in mushrooms or one with figs and proscuitto, are really inventive and delicious. And the usual favorites--pesto primo, pepperoni, etc--are just as good. I think it's the best option for pizza delivery and a darn good product. It might not change your LIFE, but you definitely won't be disappointed.

10/17/2007 Posted by ginnielizz

I just called Pagliacci on Broadway for a pizza, and I liked the sound of their seasonal special, but then I kind of balked at the price over the phone and decided to get something cheaper. The phone clerk was really sweet and patient about my waffling between options, and when the delivery gal showed up, she informed me that the pizza was free as a thank you for being a great local customer (!). When I got it upstairs and opened it up, it was the original special we'd discussed, too. I can't get over how thoughtful and kind and unexpectedly generous that was. I just feel bad that I didn't have any cash to tip the gal with, since I had placed my order using a card. They deserve more than just a Citysearch review, but this is the best I can do for now. I was so touched (and it was delicious). And by the way, in the past, the couple times we've had problems with a pizza (like once we got one with arugula and ALL the greens were brown and slimy), they sent us a coupon for a free pizza to make up for it. I love knowing you'll get treated well and fairly like that. And I seriously still can't get over the freebie tonight. I can't rave enough here -- I'm so touched!

Pros: Incredibly sweet, generous, helpful staff

Cons: Can be a bit pricy for deluxe combinations

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful

09/29/2007 Posted by olblueeyes

Here's the situation with Pagliacci: Overrated in taste, but highly consistant. Lets face it people, this pizza is good, but not "wow!, I need to call my friends!" It is number one for knowing what your gonna get, before you get it. However, I am not overly impressed with the pie compared to what else you can find around here, and its a little steep in price.

Pros: Reliable

Cons: Expensive

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful

05/12/2007 Posted by ahkat

I love Pagliacci Pizzas! I personally love thin crust pizzas, and I think they have one of the best thin crusts. I love their AGOG Primo Pizza. The roasted garlic is o delicious on the AGOG! They also have an excellent Paglliaccio salad. I can eat that salad every single day. I usually get take out, but I have been to their Bellevue location twice. Both times, the service was subpar. Once I went with a big group, and the hostess won't seat us until half the party has arrived. The resturant was mostly empty that night. That really annoyed us. Also the waitress was rude, and won't serve drinks to us until our whole party has arrived. It was ridiculous. Do take out, don't bother with the resturant

Pros: Pizza, salad

Cons: service